Följ oss

Nyheter

Hedging Versus Speculating That Metal Prices Have Bottomed

Publicerat

den

CPM Group

CPM Group on how much gold there isThe prices of gold and most other metals have fallen sharply over the past two years, to levels at which many mining companies are financially stressed. Many of these companies do not protect themselves from declining prices. Now, with current prices extremely low, they are not sure whether they should buy an insurance policy.

Mining companies’ reticence toward managing their financial exposure to the prices received for their products is rooted in several trends that emerged in the 1990s and early 2000s. Producers at that time sometimes bought insurance policies that protected them from falling prices at the expense of (a) their exposure to rising prices and (b) potentially unlimited financial risks if prices of their metal products rose at a time when they could not deliver into fixed-price hedges. All of this could have been avoided, and was by many mining companies, by using strategies that gave them (1) the floor price they sought while (2) preserving most of their exposure to rising prices and (3) capping any marked to market losses they might face at a low, pre-determined maximum level.

Meanwhile there was a misunderstanding about why shareholders invested in mining stocks, a misperception that persists to this day. Investors buy mining shares because they want exposure to rising prices, not prices. Investors will gladly lose their exposure to falling prices if they can maintain their exposure to rising prices. Often hedges were structured that did not provide exposure to rising prices and did not cap any marked to margin financial risks. With a handful of exceptions mining finance executives did not pursue these hedging structures on their own.

Today gold prices and the prices of other metals have fallen sharply from their 2011 – 2013 highs. Some mining executives are speculating that prices cannot fall further, but the history of metals prices show that prices indeed could fall further from even today’s seemingly low levels, and remain below even the average cost of production for several years.

Mining company management needs to use simple hedging structures that protect against further price deterioration while preserving their exposure to rising prices and do not put them at financial risk. This actually can be done easily with hedging strategies that have been around for decades. They also need to convey to their shareholders that when they hedge using such strategies it makes financial sense and protects the company’s viability, without putting it at risk.

All too often only fixed forward and collar hedging strategies are offered which take away the upside exposure and leave the mining companies open to large, unlimited risks. Forwards are touted as providing a floor price as an effective hedge. But when prices rise and a company has hedged using forwards at a lower price the company loses out on the upside and potentially may have to buy back the forwards at a loss. Zero-cost collars also are pushed by trading counterparties, but in reality these strategies are only marginally less destructive of shareholder value than are forwards. There is a price floor provided, but also a price cap that limits upside price participation.

Hedging should allow companies to participate in a rising gold price environment. There are various ways to do this. For example, CPM priced a zero-premium hedge for the next six months today, 18 September. The hedge locks in a floor price of $1,100 per ounce, gives the producer participation up to $1,150. Between $1,150 and $1,200 the producer would get $1,150, giving up a maximum of $50 per ounce of the upside. Above $1,200, the producer would get the market less $50, all the way up. If gold goes to $1,400 per ounce, the mining company gets $1,350. If, in the mining industry’s wildest dreams, the price goes to $2,000, the mining company gets $1,950. And, it gets to stay in business in the meantime, to enjoy the return to such halcyon days.

Many mining executives have commented that prices cannot go much lower, but prices can fall more. To say prices cannot go much lower is to speculate, and to speculate against statistically possible realities. The alternatives to hedging could trigger much more severe financial consequences.

[box]Denna analys är producerad av CPM Group och publiceras med tillstånd på Råvarumarknaden.se.[/box]

Disclaimer

Copyright CPM Group 2012. Not for reproduction or retransmission without written consent of CPM Group. Market Commentary is published by CPM Group and is distributed via e-mail. The views expressed within are solely those of CPM Group. Such information has not been verified, nor does CPM make any representation as to its accuracy or completeness.

Any statements non-factual in nature constitute only current opinions, which are subject to change. While every effort has been made to ensure that the accuracy of the material contained in the reports is correct, CPM Group cannot be held liable for errors or omissions. CPM Group is not soliciting any action based on it. Visit www.cpmgroup.com for more information.

Nyheter

Kinas elproduktion slog nytt rekord i augusti, vilket även kolkraft gjorde

Publicerat

den

Kol i Kina

Kinas officiella statistik för elproduktion har släppts för augusti och den visar att landet slog ett nytt rekord. Under augusti producerades 936 TWh elektricitet.

Stephen Stapczynski på Bloomberg lyfter fram att det är ungefär lika mycket som Japan producerar per år, vilket innebär är de producerar ungefär lika mycket elektricitet per invånare.

Kinas elproduktion kom i augusti från:

Fossil energi67 %
Vattenkraft16 %
Vind och Sol13 %
Kärnkraft5 %

Stapczynskis kollega Javier Blas uppmärksammar även att det totala rekordet inkluderade ett nytt rekord för kolkraft. Termisk energi (där nästan allting är kol) producerade 627,4 TWh under augusti. Vi rapporterade tidigare i år att Kina under första kvartalet slog ett nytt rekord i kolproduktion.

Fortsätt läsa

Nyheter

Det stigande guldpriset en utmaning för smyckesköpare

Publicerat

den

Priset på guld i svenska kronor per gram

Guldpriset når hela tiden nya höjder och det märks för folk när de ska köpa smycken. Det gör att butikerna måste justera upp sina priser löpande och kunder funderar på om det går att välja något med lägre karat eller mindre diamant. Anna Danielsson, vd på Smyckevalvet, säger att det samtidigt gör att kunderna får upp ögonen för värdet av att äga guld. Det högre guldpriset har även gjort att gamla smycken som ligger hemma i folks byrålådor kan ha fått ett överraskande högt värde.

Fortsätt läsa

Nyheter

Aktier i guldbolag laggar priset på guld

Publicerat

den

Graf som jämför priset på guld och guldaktier

Sedan år 2013 har aktierna i bolag som producerar guld inte alls hängt med prisutvecklingen på guld. I takt med att guldpriset har stigit så har avståndet bara blivit större. Detta trots att riskaptiten på aktiemarknaden i stort är högt.

I diagrammet jämförs priset på guld med Arca Gold Bugs Index, där indexet består av flera av de största guldbolagen.

Fortsätt läsa

Guldcentralen

Aktier

Annons

Gratis uppdateringar om råvarumarknaden

*

Populära