Analys
US shale oil productivity update – OPEC could choke on strongly reviving US shale oil production in 2018 if oil prices hold up in H1-17
Note: US rig count data by Baker Hughes at 19:00 CET on Friday December 16th
Crude oil comment – US shale oil productivity update – OPEC likely to choke down the road on strongly reviving US shale oil production if oil prices hold up in H1-17
The only thing which can prevent a strong rise in US shale oil rig count going forward is muted crude oil prices. The physical crude oil production effect of an additional 25 shale oil rigs into the market per month in H1-17 won’t really hit the market before H2-17 and mostly 2018. Thus price action may stay oblivious to the coming wave of US shale oil production if it disregards a potentially continued solid rise in US shale oil rigs in H1-17 on the back of OPEC cuts and associated higher prices. At the moment we can see a marginal increase in US shale production projected for January 2017. In weekly data we can see that US crude production bottomed out in September and rose 99 kb/d w/w last week.
We will not see the actual realisation of US shale oil crude production in the spot market following the rig rise in H2-16 and potentially H1-17 for quite some time. I.e. not really before H2-17 and 2018. What we can see at the moment is the reflected hedging activity from the US shale oil players who hedge on the curve for 2018 and 2019 pushing it down. Shale oil players securing their investments in newly initiated activity having been burned heavily in the previous boom and bust. That is the immediate “shadow effect” hitting the market and the crude oil curve here and now as a reflection of the rising rig count which is again an effect of higher oil prices.
According to the latest US EIA’s Drilling productivity report there were 23 shale oil rigs added per month from the start of June until November. In November alone there were 34 rigs added.
The WTI 15mth price has averaged $51.6/b since the start of June. At the time of writing it trades at $54.3/b but recently traded all the way up to $56.4/b.
Note that in the below US crude oil production scenarios we have only assumed an additional 25 rigs per month for H1-17 for Ch10 and Ch11. That is not much more than the +23 added shale oil rigs per month since June observed by the US EIA in their December drilling productivity report. Thus assuming +25 rigs per month in H1-17 is not really acceleration in rig count addition versus H2-16. However, if the crude oil price was to be significantly higher, especially the WTI 15 mth crude price, then one probably should assume a substantially higher inflow of rigs in H1-17 than what we have witnessed in H2-16.
What this all tells us is that the oil price will be highly responsive to changes in the oil market balance versus OPEC cuts or whether Libyan production will average 1 mb/d in 2017 or just 0.5 mb/d or whether global oil demand growth will be much stronger or not in 2017 or whether Russia will actually be good on its pledged cuts for H1-17 etc. Then again US shale oil rig count and thereafter production will be highly responsive to oil prices again. We have shale oil boom and bust behind us. Now we have the shale oil adaptability before us. We cannot predict all the possible uncertain events which might hit the oil market supply/demand balance in 2017 and thus impact the oil price. We can however say a lot about the responsiveness for US shale oil production and thus how the oil market dynamically will behave. Thus if OPEC gives the market elevated oil prices in H1-17, then US shale oil will give the market a serious Blue Monday in H2-17 or 2018.
What the three US crude oil production scenarios below tells us is that US crude production in 2018 is highly impacted by how many rigs are added in H1-17. If there are no more rigs in H1-17, then US crude production is good at 9.2 mb/d in 2018. However, if we just continue on the trend from H2-16 with close to 25 extra rigs per month, then US crude production jumps to 10 mb/d in 2018. Thus the 2018 global supply/demand balance is really at play in H1-17. Our numbers are of course a model. The model still fairly well shows the magnitude of sensitivities at play.
Ch1: US shale oil volume productivity growth continues to hold up at 20% per annum
Both in terms of y/y as well as 3mth/3mth annualized
Ch2: US shale oil volume productivity set to rise to 806 b/d per rig per month in January
Calculated for the 4 main US shale oil regions: Bakken, Eagle Ford, Nibrara and Permian
Ch3: The US EIA again revised higher historical US shale oil productivity by 2.1% for Nov and Dec
Data back to December 2015 were also on average revised higher.
Ch4: The productive effect of today’s some 400 rigs are as strong as 1200 rigs back at the start of 2013
Dark line gives historical rig count adjusted with today’s productivity versus productivity at the time.
An additional 23 rigs are assumed added both in December and in January.
Ch5: US shale oil production is set to start to rise rapidly near term as new production cross above losses in old production
New production here given by EIA rig productivity (December report) stretching out to Jan-17 multiplied by rig count from same report but assuming an additional 23 rigs added in Dec and Jan. In reality however there is a time-lag of 2-4 months before they really cross over.
Ch6: US EIA shale oil production just about to turn higher
Data from EIA’s drilling productivity report for December
Ch7: US crude oil production in weekly data already ticking higher (+99 kb/d w/w last week)
Ch8: US WTI15mth contract at most stimulative level (shale oil investment vise) since July 2015
Playing with numbers:
Green line: Adjust historical WTI15mth crude prices with the 20% pa (roughly) volume productivity growth
Then today’s WTI15 mth price is the most investment wise stimulative level since August 2014
Ch9: US 2018 crude oil production at 9.2 mb/d – Assuming no added US shale oil rigs after Nov 2016 and zero productivity growth
Thus rig count is fixed at 401 from Dec-16 onwards with no productivity growth
However we have already seen 21 additional shale oil rigs into the market in December but they are not added to this scenario.
Only the rigs from the US EIA’s December drilling productivity report are included in this scenario.
Thus seen in the perspective of SEB’s US crude oil model it seems to us that the US EIA assumes NO additional activated shale oil rigs into the market after Nov-16 and no additional shale oil rigs into market in 2017.
We think that the US EIA should specify its assumptions and model projections for the US shale oil rig cont and productivity which goes into their model in its monthly STEO oil reports.
Ch10: US 2018 crude oil production at 10.0 mb/d – Assuming +25 shale oil rigs per month from December 2016 to June-2017 and zero productivity growth
Then no more rigs added after June 2017 with number of US shale oil rigs fixed at 576 rigs after that
Also zero volume productivity growth here onwards from December 2016 gives the following production projection
Ch11: US 2018 crude oil production at 10.3 mb/d – Assuming +25 shale oil rigs per month from December 2016 to June-2017 and 10% pa volume productivity growth
Then no more rigs added after June 2017 with number of US shale oil rigs fixed at 576 rigs after that
But assume that US shale oil volume productivity growth continues at 10% pa. instead of the historical (and current) 20% pa.
Ch12: US shale oil profitability versus WTI 15 mth crude oil prices
Annual return for a three year investment.
Three years of crude oil production from a new shale oil well.
All money back after three years.
IP 1mth: 1000 b/d. Royalty pay: 20%. Discount rate: 10%, Three yr production after royalty and discount: 330,000 barrels, Wellhead to Cushing discount: $5/b, OPEX: $12/b, Total well cost: $8million,
All production within the hedgeable part of the WTI crude oil price curve.
Thus return should be possible to lock in at the initiation of the investment
Ch13: The WTI crude oil forward curve feeling the depression from shale oil hedging in 2018 and 2019
Likely to be increasingly heavy depression if rig count continues to rise further
Ch14: As three year annual shale oil profitability hits 16% pa
Kind regards
Bjarne Schieldrop
Chief analyst, Commodities
SEB Markets
Merchant Banking
Analys
Crude oil comment: US inventories remain well below averages despite yesterday’s build
Brent crude prices have remained stable since the sharp price surge on Monday afternoon, when the price jumped from USD 71.5 per barrel to USD 73.5 per barrel – close to current levels (now trading at USD 73.45 per barrel). The initial price spike was triggered by short-term supply disruptions at Norway’s Johan Sverdrup field and Kazakhstan’s Tengiz field.
While the disruptions in Norway have been resolved and production at Tengiz is expected to return to full capacity by the weekend, elevated prices have persisted. The market’s focus has now shifted to heightened concerns about an escalation in the war in Ukraine. This geopolitical uncertainty continues to support safe-haven assets, including gold and government bonds. Consequently, safe-haven currencies such as the U.S. dollar, Japanese yen, and Swiss franc have also strengthened.
U.S. commercial crude oil inventories (excl. SPR) increased by 0.5 million barrels last week, according to U.S DOE. This build contrasts with expectations, as consensus had predicted no change (0.0 million barrels), and the API forecast projected a much larger increase of 4.8 million barrels. With last week’s build, crude oil inventories now stand at 430.3 million barrels, yet down 18 million barrels(!) compared to the same week last year and ish 4% below the five-year average for this time of year.
Gasoline inventories rose by 2.1 million barrels (still 4% below their five-year average), defying consensus expectations of a slight draw of 0.1 million barrels. Distillate (diesel) inventories, on the other hand, fell by 0.1 million barrels, aligning closely with expectations of no change (0.0 million barrels) but also remain 4% below their five-year average. In total, combined stocks of crude, gasoline, and distillates increased by 2.5 million barrels last week.
U.S. demand data showed mixed trends. Over the past four weeks, total petroleum products supplied averaged 20.7 million barrels per day, representing a 1.2% increase compared to the same period last year. Motor gasoline demand remained relatively stable at 8.9 million barrels per day, a 0.5% rise year-over-year. In contrast, distillate fuel demand continued to weaken, averaging 3.8 million barrels per day, down 6.4% from a year ago. Jet fuel demand also softened, falling 1.3% compared to the same four-week period in 2023.
Analys
China is turning the corner and oil sentiment will likely turn with it
Brent crude is maintaining its gains from Monday and ticking yet higher. Brent crude made a jump of 3.2% on Monday to USD 73.5/b and has managed to maintain the gain since then. Virtually no price change yesterday and opening this morning at USD 73.3/b.
Emerging positive signs from the Chinese economy may lift oil market sentiment. Chinese economic weakness in general and shockingly weak oil demand there has been pestering the oil price since its peak of USD 92.2/b in mid-April. Net Chinese crude and product imports has been negative since May as measured by 3mth y/y changes. This measure reached minus 10% in July and was still minus 3% in September. And on a year to Sep, y/y it is down 2%. Chinese oil demand growth has been a cornerstone of global oil demand over the past decades accounting for a growth of around half a million barrels per day per year or around 40% of yearly global oil demand growth. Electrification and gassification (LNG HDTrucking) of transportation is part of the reason, but that should only have weakened China’s oil demand growth and not turned it abruptly negative. Historically it has been running at around +3-4% pa.
With a sense of ’no end in sight’ for China’ ills and with a trade war rapidly approaching with Trump in charge next year, the oil bears have been in charge of the oil market. Oil prices have moved lower and lower since April. Refinery margins have also fallen sharply along with weaker oil products demand. The front-month gasoil crack to Brent peaked this year at USD 34.4/b (premium to Brent) in February and fell all the way to USD 14.4/b in mid October. Several dollar below its normal seasonal level. Now however it has recovered to a more normal, healthy seasonal level of USD 18.2/b.
But Chinese stimulus measures are already working. The best immediate measure of that is the China surprise index which has rallied from -40 at the end of September to now +20. This is probably starting to filter in to the oil market sentiment.
The market has for quite some time now been staring down towards the USD 60/b. But this may now start to change with a bit more optimistic tones emerging from the Chinese economy.
China economic surprise index (white). Front-month ARA Gasoil crack to Brent in USD/b (blue)
The IEA could be too bearish by up to 0.8 mb/d. IEA’s calculations for Q3-24 are off by 0.8 mb/d. OECD inventories fell by 1.16 mb/d in Q3 according to the IEA’s latest OMR. But according to the IEA’s supply/demand balance the decline should only have been 0.38 mb/d. I.e. the supply/demand balance of IEA for Q3-24 was much less bullish than how the inventories actually developed by a full 0.8 mb/d. If we assume that the OECD inventory changes in Q3-24 is the ”proof of the pudding”, then IEA’s estimated supply/demand balance was off by a full 0.8 mb/d. That is a lot. It could have a significant consequence for 2025 where the IEA is estimating that call-on-OPEC will decline by 0.9 mb/d y/y according to its estimated supply/demand balance. But if the IEA is off by 0.8 mb/d in Q3-24, it could be equally off by 0.8 mb/d for 2025 as a whole as well. Leading to a change in the call-on-OPEC of only 0.1 mb/d y/y instead. Story by Bloomberg: {NSN SMXSUYT1UM0W <GO>}. And looking at US oil inventories they have consistently fallen significantly more than normal since June this year. See below.
Later today at 16:30 CET we’ll have the US oil inventory data. Bearish indic by API, but could be a bullish surprise yet again. Last night the US API indicated that US crude stocks rose by 4.8 mb, gasoline stocks fell by 2.5 mb and distillates fell by 0.7 mb. In total a gain of 1.6 mb. Total US crude and product stocks normally decline by 3.7 mb for week 46.
The trend since June has been that US oil inventories have been falling significantly versus normal seasonal trends. US oil inventories stood 16 mb above the seasonal 2015-19 average on 21 June. In week 45 they ended 34 mb below their 2015-19 seasonal average. Recent news is that US Gulf refineries are running close to max in order to satisfy Lat Am demand for oil products.
US oil inventories versus the 2015-19 seasonal averages.
Analys
Crude oil comment: Europe’s largest oil field halted – driving prices higher
Since market opening on Monday, November 18, Brent crude prices have climbed steadily. Starting the week at approximately USD 70.7 per barrel, prices rose to USD 71.5 per barrel by noon yesterday. However, in the afternoon, Brent crude surged by nearly USD 2 per barrel, reaching USD 73.5 per barrel, which is close to where we are currently trading.
This sharp price increase has been driven by supply disruptions at two major oil fields: Norway’s Johan Sverdrup and Kazakhstan’s Tengiz. The Brent benchmark is now continuing to trade above USD 73 per barrel as the market reacts to heightened concerns about short-term supply tightness.
Norway’s Johan Sverdrup field, Europe’s largest and one of the top 10 globally in terms of estimated recoverable reserves, temporarily halted production on Monday afternoon due to an onshore power outage. According to Equinor, the issue was quickly identified but resulted in a complete shutdown of the field. Restoration efforts are underway. With a production capacity of 755,000 barrels per day, Sverdrup accounts for approximately 36% of Norway’s total oil output, making it a critical player in the country’s production. The unexpected outage has significantly supported Brent prices as the market evaluates its impact on overall supply.
Adding to the bullish momentum, supply constraints at Kazakhstan’s Tengiz field have further intensified concerns. Tengiz, with a production capacity of around 700,000 barrels per day, has seen output cut by approximately 30% this month due to ongoing repairs, exceeding earlier estimates of a 20% reduction. Repairs are expected to conclude by November 23, but in the meantime, supply tightness persists, amplifying market vol.
On a broader scale, a pullback in the U.S. dollar yesterday (down 0.15%) provided additional tailwinds for crude prices, making oil more attractive to international buyers. However, over the past few weeks, Brent crude has alternated between gains and losses as market participants juggle multiple factors, including U.S. monetary policy, concerns over Chinese demand, and the evolving supply strategy of OPEC+.
The latter remains a critical factor, as unused production capacity within OPEC continues to exert downward pressure on prices. An acceleration in the global economy will be crucial to improving demand fundamentals.
Despite these short-term fluctuations, we see encouraging signs of a recovering global economy and remain moderately bullish. We are holding to our price forecast of USD 75 per barrel in 2025, followed by USD 87.5 in 2026.
-
Analys3 veckor sedan
Crude oil comment: A price rise driven by fundamentals
-
Analys3 veckor sedan
Crude oil comment: Recent ’geopolitical relief’ seems premature
-
Nyheter4 veckor sedan
Guldpriset stiger hela tiden till nya rekord
-
Nyheter3 veckor sedan
Oljepriset kommer gå upp till 500 USD per fat år 2030
-
Nyheter3 veckor sedan
ABB och Blykalla samarbetar om teknikutveckling för små modulära reaktorer
-
Analys2 veckor sedan
Brent resumes after yesterday’s price tumble
-
Nyheter2 veckor sedan
Michel Rufli förklarar vad som händer på guldmarknaden
-
Analys2 veckor sedan
Crude oil comment: Iran’s silence hints at a new geopolitical reality