Analys
US crude recovery could cover all OPEC cuts
Over the last two weeks Brent crude has fallen close to $4/b. Market perception has shifted from “OPEC will do the job and US crude production will recover gradually” to instead “Can OPEC do the job? and US production is rebounding strongly”. The hypothesis that US crude oil production will only recover gradually and slowly as long as the oil price stays below $60/b has clearly fallen. The US EIA projects that US crude production will move above its April 2015 peak of 9.6 mb/d in February 2018. We think that this will happen already in October 2017. However, if we extrapolate the average weekly increase since the start of 2017 (+33.9 kb/d/week) we get that with a starting point of 9.1 mb/d on the 10th of March then US crude production will pass the 9.6 mb/d already in June 2017. Thus full attention to the US EIA’s weekly publishing of US crude production is clearly warranted.
If US production had only recovered slowly as long as the oil price stayed below $60/b, then it would easily have been in OPEC’s power to drive the oil price rather quickly back to $60/b. However, US shale oil rig count rose by 7 rigs per week in H2-17 when the WTI 15mth forward price averaged around $52/b in H2-16. When that part of the forward curve was pushed up to $55-56/b following OPEC’s decision to cut it lifted the weekly rig count additions to 9.2 rigs/week on average so far in 2017. Along with the latest sell-off the WTI 15mths price has now fallen back to $50.5/b. This can be interpreted as an effort by the market to push back the current acceleration in shale oil investments. If this price stays at this level of about $50/b then we won’t know the effect of this before some 6-8 weeks down the road which is the typical lag between price action to rig count reaction. Thus the growth in US shale oil rig count is likely to continue unabated all through April.
OPEC will meet on the 25th of May this year to discuss whether to continue its cuts or not. US crude oil production stood at 8.7 mb/d when OPEC decided to cut at its 30th November meeting in 2016. That was only 0.25 mb/b above the US crude production trough of 8.45 mb/d in July/August 2016. The general view then was clearly that US crude production would recover gradually. There would not be much acceleration unless the oil price moved up to $60/b. OPEC decided to cut 1.16 mb/d from its October production level which lead to a production target of 31.8 mb/d for H1-17. So far OPEC has cut 0.4 mb/d less than planned with an averaged Jan/Feb production of 32.2 mb/d. I.e. the organisation has cut some 0.8 mb/d versus its October 2016 level. Back in November a US crude production rebound was not even on the horizon and not much discussed. The US EIA’s monthly report only stretched out to the end of 2017 with a prediction that US crude production would hit 8.94 mb/d in Dec 2017 which was just 250 kb/d above the US crude production in November 2016.
Now it all looks different. If we look away from EIA’s projection of US hitting 9.6 mb/d in Feb 2018 and instead focus on the latest weekly production data of 9.1 mb/d and extend it with the growth trend so far this year then US production would hit close to 9.5 mb/d just when OPEC’s members meet on the 25th of May. US production would then have increased by close to 0.8 mb/d since OPEC decided to cut in November 2016. That is close to exactly what OPEC has cut in Jan and Feb. Thus if OPEC’s compliance to the decided cuts don’t rise from here then US crude oil production recovery could end up rising equaly much as OPEC ended up cutting. The previous oil minister in Saudi Arabia, Ali al-Naimi’s words that an OPEC cut would only yield a lower market share while not necessarily lift the oil price may start to ring in the back of the head of OPEC’s members. We don’t expect OPEC to extend its cuts into H2-17. We have this itching feeling that OPEC compliance to cuts may start to erode towards the end of H1-17. Especially if the expectation is that there will be no further cuts.
Speculative market repositioning helped to shift oil prices lower
The pullback in the oil price last two weeks was clearly a repositioning in speculative positions as holders of long positions started to be concerned about the increasingly visible strong US production recovery. Net long speculative positions in WTI reached close to 600 mb some 4 weeks ago but have now sold off back down to 500 mb. A more neutral level is however around 350 mb. Thus there is still risk for further bearish repositioning.
We still expect Brent crude at $57.5/b in Q2-17 before falling back to $52.5/b in Q4-17
We are still positive for crude oil prices into Q2-17 where we expect front month Brent to average $57.5/b. We expect to see inventories to start to draw any moment as OPEC’s elevated production in Nov and Dec now increasingly is assimilated. Global refineries are also now increasingly coming back on line thus starting to process crude oil again. As oil inventories continues to draw as it did all through H2-16 we expect the forward crude oil curves to flip fully into backwardation. This will then enable the Brent crude oil front month contract to move up to $57.5/b while still leaving the WTI 15mth contract at around $51-52/b. Our outlook for Q2-17 is however at risk if US crude oil production continues to grow at its current trend rate. We still expect Brent crude to head down to average $52.5/b in Q4-17 in order to cool US shale oil production growth.
We expect OECD inventories to draw down 160 million barrels in 2017
The market was disappointed when it heard from IEA that OECD inventories rose by 48 mb in January. In perspective however, OECD inventories normally increase by some 30 mb from Dec to Jan. Thus the increase in inventories was only 18 mb more than normal. What is striking is that OECD’s inventories trended downwards all through H2-16 and ended down y/y for the first time in a long, long time in both December and January. And this was even without the help of OPEC cuts. We still expect the oil market to run a deficit of some 0.4 mb/d in 2017 thus resulting in a steady draw in inventories. Thus we have passed the OECD peak inventories and we are now heading downwards. The higher activation of US shale oil rigs than expected over the last two to three months has however impacted our projected supply/demand balance for 2018 leading to virtually no deficit in 2018 and thus very limited draws. Thus 2018 look likely to be a waiting year for the oil market with still plenty of oil in OECD inventories and with few pressure points.
Ch1: OECD down y/y for the first time in a long time in Dec and Jan
We are past the peak OECD inventories. To draw down from here
Ch2: Strong US production growth recovery is posing a problem for OPEC
OPEC cuts unlikely to continue in H2-17 as US production may reach 9.5 mb/d already in late May (trend extrapolation)
Ch3: Latest sell-off has increased the depth of front end crude curve contango
This contango and discount for spot crude prices versus longer dated contracts is just what OPEC wants to get away from
The 1-2 year forward WTI curve has shifted down to $50/b which would reduce the profitability for new shale oil investments
Ch4: Net long speculative WTI positions has pulled back but are still high
Now standing at 500,000 contracts or 500 million barrels.
Neutral level would be around 350 million barrels
Ch5: OPEC production at 32.16 mb/d in Feb and thus some 350 kb/d above its target.
Will OPEC compliance fall apart if it becomes increasingly clear that there will be no cuts in H2-17?
Ch6: We still expect a deficit the next three years despite strong US production growth
The balance assumes no OPEC cuts after H1-17
Ch7: Due to current high OECD inventories the global oil market is fine all through 2017 and 2018.
Not a lot of pressure points to be seen before 2019
Ch8: And yes, we are bullish US crude oil production but even more than that is needed in 2019
Then it all boils down to “too little too late” or “too much too soon”.
The US EIA is lifting its prognosis every month all since last July.
We expect them to continue to do that going forward as well as the EIA prognosis is still way behind the curve in our view.
Kind regards
Bjarne Schieldrop
Chief analyst, Commodities
SEB Markets
Merchant Banking
Analys
Brent on a rollercoaster between bullish sanctions and bearish tariffs. Tariffs and demand side fears in focus today
Brent crude rallied to a high of USD 75.29/b yesterday, but wasn’t able to hold on to it and closed the day at USD 74.49/b. Brent crude has now crossed above both the 50- and 100-day moving average with the 200dma currently at USD 76.1/b. This morning it is trading a touch lower at USD 74.3/b
Brent riding a rollercoaster between bullish sanctions and bearish tariffs. Biden sanctions drove Brent to USD 82.63/b in mid-January. Trump tariffs then pulled it down to USD 68.33/b in early March with escalating concerns for oil demand growth and a sharp selloff in equities. New sanctions from Trump on Iran, Venezuela and threats of such also towards Russia then drove Brent crude back up to its recent high of USD 75.29/b. Brent is currently driving a rollercoaster between new demand damaging tariffs from Trump and new supply tightening sanctions towards oil producers (Iran, Venezuela, Russia) from Trump as well.
’Liberation day’ is today putting demand concerns in focus. Today we have ’Liberation day’ in the US with new, fresh tariffs to be released by Trump. We know it will be negative for trade, economic growth and thus oil demand growth. But we don’t know how bad it will be as the effects comes a little bit down the road. Especially bad if it turns into a global trade war escalating circus.
Focus today will naturally be on the negative side of demand. It will be hard for Brent to rally before we have the answer to what the extent these tariffs will be. Republicans lost the Supreme Court race in Wisconsin yesterday. So maybe the new Tariffs will be to the lighter side if Trump feels that he needs to tread a little bit more carefully.
OPEC+ controlling the oil market amid noise from tariffs and sanctions. In the background though sits OPEC+ with a huge surplus production capacity which it now will slice and dice out with gradual increases going forward. That is somehow drowning in the noise from sanctions and tariffs. But all in all, it is still OPEC+ who is setting the oil price these days.
US oil inventory data likely to show normal seasonal rise. Later today we’ll have US oil inventory data for last week. US API indicated last night that US crude and product stocks rose 4.4 mb last week. Close to the normal seasonal rise in week 13.
Higher last week and today as sanctions bite harder than recession fears. Brent crude gained 2% last week with a close on Friday of USD 73.63/b. It traded in a range of USD 71.8-74.17/b. It traded mostly higher through the week despite sharp, new selloffs in equities along with US consumer expectations falling to lowest level since 2013 (Consumer Conf. Board Expectations.) together with signals of new tariffs from the White House. Ahead this week looms the ”US Liberation Day” on April 2 when the White House will announce major changes in the country’s trade policy. Equity markets are down across the board this morning while Brent crude has traded higher and lower and is currently up 0.5% at USD 74.0/b at the moment.
New US sanctions towards Iran and Venezuela and threats of new sanctions towards Russia. New sanctions on Venezuela and Iran are helping to keep the market tight. Oil production in Venezuela reached 980 kb/d in February following a steady rise from 310 kb/d in mid-2020 while it used to produce 2.3 mb/d up to 2016. Trump last week allowed Chevron to import oil from Venezuela until 27 May. But he also said that any country taking oil or gas from Venezuela after 2 April will face 25% tariffs on any goods exported into the US. Trump is also threatening to sanction Russian oil further if Putin doesn’t move towards a peace solution with Ukraine.
The OPEC+ to meet on Saturday 5 April to decide whether to lift production in May or not. The OPEC+ Joint Ministerial Monitoring Committee will meet on Saturday 5 April to review market conditions, compliance by the members versus their production targets and most importantly decide whether they shall increase production further in May following first production hike in April. We find it highly likely that they will continue to lift production also in May.
OPEC(+) crashed the oil price twice to curb US shale, but it kicked back quickly. OPEC(+) has twice crashed the oil price in an effort to hurt and disable booming US shale oil production. First in 2014/15/16 and then in the spring of 2020. The first later led to the creation of OPEC+ through the Declaration of Cooperation (DoC) in the autumn of 2016. The second was in part driven by Covid-19 as well as a quarrel between Russia and Saudi Arabia over market strategy. But the fundamental reason for that quarrel and the crash in the oil price was US shale oil producers taking more and more market share.
The experience by OPEC+ through both of these two events was that US shale oil quickly kicked back even bigger and better yielding very little for OPEC+ to cheer about.
OPEC+ has harvested an elevated oil price but is left with a large spare capacity. The group has held back large production volumes since Spring 2020. It yielded the group USD 100/b in 2022 (with some help from the war in Ukraine), USD 81/b on average in 2023/24 and USD 75/b so far this year. The group is however left with a large spare capacity with little room to place it back into the market without crashing the price. It needs non-OPEC+ in general and US shale oil especially to yield room for it to re-enter.
A quick crash and painful blow to US shale oil is no longer the strategy. The strategy this time is clearly very different from the previous two times. It is no longer about trying to give US shale oil producers a quick, painful blow in the hope that the sector will stay down for an extended period. It is instead a lengthier process of finding the pain-point of US shale oil players (and other non-OPEC+ producers) through a gradual increase in production by OPEC+ and a gradual decline in the oil price down to the point where non-OPEC+ in general and US liquids production especially will gradually tick lower and yield room to the reentry of OPEC+ spare capacity. It does not look like a plan for a crash and a rush, but instead a tedious process where OPEC+ will gradually force its volumes back into the market.
Where is the price pain-point for US shale oil players? The Brent crude oil price dropped from USD 84/b over the year to September last year to USD 74/b on average since 1 September. The values for US WTI were USD 79/b and USD 71/b respectively. A drop of USD 9/b for both crudes. There has however been no visible reaction in the US drilling rig count following the USD 9/b fall. The US drilling rig count has stayed unchanged at around 480 rigs since mid-2024 with the latest count at 484 operating rigs. While US liquids production growth is slowing, it is still set to grow by 580 kb/d in 2025 and 445 kb/d in 2026 (US EIA).
US shale oil average cost-break-even at sub USD 50/b (BNEF). Industry says it is USD 65/b. BNEF last autumn estimated that all US shale oil production fields had a cost-break-even below USD 60/b with a volume weighted average just below USD 50/b while conventional US onshore oil had a break-even of USD 65/b. A recent US Dallas Fed report which surveyed US oil producers did however yield a response that the US oil industry on average needed USD 65/b to break even. That is more than USD 15/b higher than the volume weighted average of the BNEF estimates.
The WTI 13-to-24-month strip is at USD 64/b. Probably the part of the curve controlling activity. As such it needs to move lower to curb US shale oil activity. The WTI price is currently at USD 69.7/b. But the US shale oil industry today works on a ”12-month drilling first, then fracking after” production cycle. When it considers whether to drill more or less or not, it is typically on a deferred 12-month forward price basis. The average WTI price for months 13 to 24 is today USD 64/b. The price signal from this part of the curve is thus already down at the pain-point highlighted by the US shale oil industry. In order to yield zero growth and possibly contraction in US shale oil production, this part of the curve needs to move below that point.
The real pain-point is where we’ll see US drilling rig count starting to decline. We still don’t know whether the actual average pain-point is around USD 50/b as BNEF estimate it is or whether it is closer to USD 65/b which the US shale oil bosses say it is. The actual pain-point is where we’ll see further decline in US drilling rig count. And there has been no visible change in the rig count since mid-2024. The WTI 13-to-24-month prices need to fall further to reveal where the US shale oil industry’ actual pain-point is. And then a little bit more in order to slow production growth further and likely into some decline to make room for reactivation of OPEC+ spare capacity.
The WTI forward price curve. The average of 13 to 24 month is now USD 64.3/b.
The average 13-to-24-month prices on the WTI price curve going back to primo January 2022. Recently dropping below USD 65/b for some extended period.
Brent has defied bearish equities for three days but is losing its stamina today. Brent gained 0.3% yesterday with a close of USD 74.03/b, the highest close since 27 February and almost at the high of the day. It traded as low as USD 73.23/b. Brent has now defied the equity selloff three days in a row by instead ticking steadily higher. A sign of current spot tightness. This morning however it is losing some of its stamina and is down 0.5% at USD 73.7/b along with negative equities and yet higher gold prices.
The new US Iran sanctions is creating frictions in getting its oil to market and helps keeping oil market tight. Part of the current tightness is due to the new US sanctions on Iran which. Ships containing 17 mb of its oil now sits idle east of Malaysia waiting (Bloomberg) for ship-to-ship transfers with China teapot refineries the normal final destination. But the latest US sanctions has probably made these refineries much more cautious. More friction before Iranian oil is reaching its final destination if at all. Tighter market.
Lower Saudi OSPs for May is expected. A signal of a softer market ahead as OPEC+ lifts production. Saudi Aramco is expected to reduce it official selling price (OSPs) for Arab Light to Asia for May deliveries by USD 2/b. A measure to make its oil more competitive in relative to other crudes suppliers. It is also a sign of a softer market ahead. Naturally so since OPEC+ is set to lift production in April and also most likely in May. If Saudi Aramco reduces its OSPs to Asia for May across its segments of crudes, then it is a signal it is expecting softer oil market conditions. But news today is only discussing Arab Light while the main tightness int the market today is centered around medium sour crude segment. A lowering of the OSPs for the heavier and more sour grades will thus be a more forceful bearish signal.
Front-end backwardation may ease as the Brent May contract rolls off early next week. The Brent May future will roll off early next week. It will be interesting to see how that affects the front-end 1-3mth backwardation as it is shifted out into summer where a softer market is expected.
Brent is boring like crazy with 30dma annualized volatility of just 21%. Waiting for something to happen.
Brent crude has defied three days of bearish equity markets and ticked higher instead. Caving in a bit this morning with yet another day of bearish equities and bullish gold.
Brent on a rollercoaster between bullish sanctions and bearish tariffs. Tariffs and demand side fears in focus today
Våren präglas av svängigt elpris och ankkurva
Guld kostar över 3100 USD per uns och 1 miljoner kronor per kilo
Oil gains as sanctions bite harder than recession fears
Danska Seaborg Technologies siktar på serieproduktion av smältsaltsreaktorer till mitten av 2030-talet
USA är världens största importör av aluminium
Oversold. Rising 1-3mth time-spreads. Possibly rebounding to USD 73.5/b before downside ensues
Crude oil comment: Unable to rebound as the US SPX is signaling dark clouds on the horizon
Crude oil comment: Not so fragile yet. If it was it would have sold off more yesterday
A deliberate measure to push oil price lower but it is not the opening of the floodgates
-
Nyheter3 veckor sedanUSA är världens största importör av aluminium
-
Analys4 veckor sedan
Oversold. Rising 1-3mth time-spreads. Possibly rebounding to USD 73.5/b before downside ensues
-
Analys3 veckor sedan
Crude oil comment: Unable to rebound as the US SPX is signaling dark clouds on the horizon
-
Analys3 veckor sedan
Crude oil comment: Not so fragile yet. If it was it would have sold off more yesterday
-
Analys4 veckor sedan
A deliberate measure to push oil price lower but it is not the opening of the floodgates
-
Nyheter2 veckor sedanPriset på koppar skiljer sig åt efter tariffer
-
Analys2 veckor sedan
Oil prices climb, but fundamentals will keep rallies in check
-
Nyheter2 veckor sedanPå 15 år eldar Kina lika mycket kol som USA gjort under hela sin historia