Följ oss

Analys

Oil gains as sanctions bite harder than recession fears

Publicerat

den

SEB - analysbrev på råvaror

Higher last week and today as sanctions bite harder than recession fears. Brent crude gained 2% last week with a close on Friday of USD 73.63/b. It traded in a range of USD 71.8-74.17/b. It traded mostly higher through the week despite sharp, new selloffs in equities along with US consumer expectations falling to lowest level since 2013 (Consumer Conf. Board Expectations.) together with signals of new tariffs from the White House. Ahead this week looms the ”US Liberation Day” on April 2 when the White House will announce major changes in the country’s trade policy. Equity markets are down across the board this morning while Brent crude has traded higher and lower and is currently up 0.5% at USD 74.0/b at the moment.

Bjarne Schieldrop, Chief analyst commodities, SEB
Bjarne Schieldrop, Chief analyst commodities, SEB

New US sanctions towards Iran and Venezuela and threats of new sanctions towards Russia. New sanctions on Venezuela and Iran are helping to keep the market tight. Oil production in Venezuela reached 980 kb/d in February following a steady rise from 310 kb/d in mid-2020 while it used to produce 2.3 mb/d up to 2016. Trump last week allowed Chevron to import oil from Venezuela until 27 May. But he also said that any country taking oil or gas from Venezuela after 2 April will face 25% tariffs on any goods exported into the US. Trump is also threatening to sanction Russian oil further if Putin doesn’t move towards a peace solution with Ukraine.

The OPEC+ to meet on Saturday 5 April to decide whether to lift production in May or not. The OPEC+ Joint Ministerial Monitoring Committee will meet on Saturday 5 April to review market conditions, compliance by the members versus their production targets and most importantly decide whether they shall increase production further in May following first production hike in April. We find it highly likely that they will continue to lift production also in May.

OPEC(+) crashed the oil price twice to curb US shale, but it kicked back quickly. OPEC(+) has twice crashed the oil price in an effort to hurt and disable booming US shale oil production. First in 2014/15/16 and then in the spring of 2020. The first later led to the creation of OPEC+ through the Declaration of Cooperation (DoC) in the autumn of 2016. The second was in part driven by Covid-19 as well as a quarrel between Russia and Saudi Arabia over market strategy. But the fundamental reason for that quarrel and the crash in the oil price was US shale oil producers taking more and more market share.

The experience by OPEC+ through both of these two events was that US shale oil quickly kicked back even bigger and better yielding very little for OPEC+ to cheer about.

OPEC+ has harvested an elevated oil price but is left with a large spare capacity. The group has held back large production volumes since Spring 2020. It yielded the group USD 100/b in 2022 (with some help from the war in Ukraine), USD 81/b on average in 2023/24 and USD 75/b so far this year. The group is however left with a large spare capacity with little room to place it back into the market without crashing the price. It needs non-OPEC+ in general and US shale oil especially to yield room for it to re-enter. 

A quick crash and painful blow to US shale oil is no longer the strategy. The strategy this time is clearly very different from the previous two times. It is no longer about trying to give US shale oil producers a quick, painful blow in the hope that the sector will stay down for an extended period. It is instead a lengthier process of finding the pain-point of US shale oil players (and other non-OPEC+ producers) through a gradual increase in production by OPEC+ and a gradual decline in the oil price down to the point where non-OPEC+ in general and US liquids production especially will gradually tick lower and yield room to the reentry of OPEC+ spare capacity. It does not look like a plan for a crash and a rush, but instead a tedious process where OPEC+ will gradually force its volumes back into the market.

Where is the price pain-point for US shale oil players? The Brent crude oil price dropped from USD 84/b over the year to September last year to USD 74/b on average since 1 September. The values for US WTI were USD 79/b and USD 71/b respectively. A drop of USD 9/b for both crudes. There has however been no visible reaction in the US drilling rig count following the USD 9/b fall. The US drilling rig count has stayed unchanged at around 480 rigs since mid-2024 with the latest count at 484 operating rigs. While US liquids production growth is slowing, it is still set to grow by 580 kb/d in 2025 and 445 kb/d in 2026 (US EIA).

US shale oil average cost-break-even at sub USD 50/b (BNEF). Industry says it is USD 65/b. BNEF last autumn estimated that all US shale oil production fields had a cost-break-even below USD 60/b with a volume weighted average just below USD 50/b while conventional US onshore oil had a break-even of USD 65/b. A recent US Dallas Fed report which surveyed US oil producers did however yield a response that the US oil industry on average needed USD 65/b to break even. That is more than USD 15/b higher than the volume weighted average of the BNEF estimates.

The WTI 13-to-24-month strip is at USD 64/b. Probably the part of the curve controlling activity. As such it needs to move lower to curb US shale oil activity. The WTI price is currently at USD 69.7/b. But the US shale oil industry today works on a ”12-month drilling first, then fracking after” production cycle. When it considers whether to drill more or less or not, it is typically on a deferred 12-month forward price basis. The average WTI price for months 13 to 24 is today USD 64/b. The price signal from this part of the curve is thus already down at the pain-point highlighted by the US shale oil industry. In order to yield zero growth and possibly contraction in US shale oil production, this part of the curve needs to move below that point.

The real pain-point is where we’ll see US drilling rig count starting to decline. We still don’t know whether the actual average pain-point is around USD 50/b as BNEF estimate it is or whether it is closer to USD 65/b which the US shale oil bosses say it is. The actual pain-point is where we’ll see further decline in US drilling rig count. And there has been no visible change in the rig count since mid-2024. The WTI 13-to-24-month prices need to fall further to reveal where the US shale oil industry’ actual pain-point is. And then a little bit more in order to slow production growth further and likely into some decline to make room for reactivation of OPEC+ spare capacity.

The WTI forward price curve. The average of 13 to 24 month is now USD 64.3/b.

The WTI forward price curve. The average of 13 to 24 month is now USD 64.3/b.
Source: SEB graph and highlights, Bloomberg data

The average 13-to-24-month prices on the WTI price curve going back to primo January 2022. Recently dropping below USD 65/b for some extended period.

The average 13-to-24-month prices on the WTI price curve going back to primo January 2022. Recently dropping below USD 65/b for some extended period.
Source: SEB graph and highlights, Bloomberg data
Fortsätt läsa
Annons

Gratis uppdateringar om råvarumarknaden

*

Analys

Physical easing. Iran risk easing. But Persian Gulf risk cannot fully fade before US war ships are pulled away

Publicerat

den

SEB - analysbrev på råvaror

Traded down 3.7% last week as Iranian risk faded a bit. Brent crude traded in a range of $65.19 – 69.76/b last week. In the end it traded down 3.7% with a close of $68.05/b. It was unable to challenge the peak of $71.89/b from the previous week when the market got its first nervous shake as Trump threatened Iran with an armada of US war ships.

Bjarne Schieldrop, Chief analyst commodities, SEB
Bjarne Schieldrop, Chief analyst commodities, SEB

The market has started to cool down a bit with US and Iran in talks in Oman on Friday and Brent crude is easing 0.9% this morning to $67.4/b in an extension of that. As we have stated before we think the probability is very low for a scenario where the US attacks Iran in such a way that it risks an uncontrollable escalation with possible large scale disruption of oil out of the Strait of Hormuz and thus a massive spike in the oil price. That would endanger Trump’s mid-term election which is already challenged with unhappy US voters complaining about affordability and that Trump is spending too much time on foreign issues.

A statement by Trump last week that India had agreed not to buy Russian crude turns out to have little substance as India has agreed to no such thing on paper. The statement last week naturally supported oil prices as the market is already struggling with a two tire market with legal versus illegal barrels. There is a lot of friction in the market for sanctioned crude oil barrels from Iran and Russia. If India had agreed not to buy Russian crude oil then the market for legal barrels would have been tighter.

The physical market has been tighter than expected. And the recent concerns over Iranian risk has come on top of that. The market is probably starting calm down regarding the Iranian risk. But the physical tightness is also going to ease gradually over the coming couple of weeks. CPC blend exports averaged 1.5 mb/d last year, but were down to less than 1 mb/d in January due to a combination of factors. Drone attacks by Ukraine in late November. The Tengiz field has been disrupted by fires. Adverse winter weather has also been a problem. US crude oil production has also been disrupted by a fierce winter storm. But these issues are fading with supply reviving over the next couple of weeks.

The physical tightness is likely going to ease over the next couple of weeks. The market may also have started to get used to the Iranian situation. But the Iranian risk premium cannot be fully defused as long as US warships are located where they are with their guns and rockets pointing towards Iran.

Fortsätt läsa

Analys

Brent crude will pull back if the US climbs down its threats towards Iran

Publicerat

den

SEB - analysbrev på råvaror

Brent crude rose 2.7% last week to $65.88/b with a gain on Friday of 2.8%. Unusually cold US winter weather with higher heating oil demand and likely US oil supply outages was probably part of the bullish drive at the end of last week. But US threats towards Iran with USS Abraham Lincoln being deployed to the Middle East was probably more important.

Bjarne Schieldrop, Chief analyst commodities, SEB
Bjarne Schieldrop, Chief analyst commodities, SEB

Brent crude has maintained the gains it got from 8 January onwards when it rose from the $60/b-line and up to around $65/b on the back of Iranian riots where the US added fuel to the fire by threatening to attack Iran in support of the rioters. This morning Brent has tested the upside to $66.54/b. That is short of the $66.82/b from 14 January and Brent has given back part of the early gains this morning and is currently trading close to unchanged versus Friday’s close with a dollar decline of 0.4% not enough to add much boost to the price yet at least.

Brent crude front-month prices in USD/b

Brent crude front-month prices in USD/b
Source: Bloomberg

The rally in Brent crude from the $60/b-line to its current level of $65-66/b seems to be tightly linked to an elevated risk of the US attacking Iran in support of the rioters. Bloomberg reported on Saturday that the US has dispatched the USS Abraham Lincoln aircraft carrier and its associated strike group to the Middle East. It is a similar force which the US deployed to the Caribbean Sea just weeks before the 3 January operation where Maduro was captured. The probability of a US/Israeli attack on Iran is pegged at 65-70% by geopolitical risk assessment firms Eurasia Group and Rapidan Energy Group. Such a high probability explains much of the recent rally in Brent crude.

The recent rally in Brent crude is not a signal from the oil market that the much discussed global surplus has been called off. If we look at the shape of the Brent crude oil curve it is currently heavily front-end backwardated with the curve sloping upwards in contango thereafter. It signals front-end tightness or near term geopolitical risk premium followed by surplus. If the market had called off the views of a surplus, then the whole Brent forward curve would have been much flatter and without the intermediate deep dip in the curve. The shape of the Brent curve is telling us that the market is concerned right now for what might happen in Iran, but it still maintains and overall view of surplus and stock building unless OPEC+ cuts back on supply.

It also implies that Brent crude will fall back if the US pulls back from its threats of attacking Iran.

Brent crude forward curves in USD/b.

Brent crude forward curves in USD/b.
Source: Bloomberg
Fortsätt läsa

Analys

Oil market assigns limited risks to Iranian induced supply disruptions

Publicerat

den

SEB - analysbrev på råvaror

Falling back this morning. Brent crude traded from an intraday low of $59.75/b last Monday to an intraday high of $63.92/b on Friday and a close that day of $63.34/b. Driven higher by the rising riots in Iran. Brent is trading slightly lower this morning at $63.0/b.

Bjarne Schieldrop, Chief analyst commodities, SEB
Bjarne Schieldrop, Chief analyst commodities, SEB

Iranian riots and risk of supply disruption in the Middle East takes center stage. The Iranian public is rioting in response to rapidly falling living conditions. The current oppressive regime has been ruling the country for 46 years. The Iranian economy has rapidly deteriorated the latest years along with the mismanagement of the economy, a water crisis, encompassing corruption with the Iranian Revolutionary Guard Corps at the center and with US sanctions on top. The public has had enough and is now rioting. SEB’s EM Strategist Erik Meyersson wrote the following on the Iranian situation yesterday: ”Iran is on the brink – but of what?” with one statement being ”…the regime seems to lack a comprehensive set of solutions to solve the socioeconomic problems”. That is of course bad news for the regime. What can it do? Erik’s takeaway is that it is an open question what this will lead to while also drawing up different possible scenarios.

Personally I fear that this may end very badly for the rioters. That the regime will use absolute force to quash the riots. Kill many, many more and arrest and torture anyone who still dare to protest. I do not have high hopes for a transition to another regime. I bet that Iranian’s telephone lines to its diverse group of autocratic friends currently are running red-hot with ”friendly” recommendations of how to quash the riots. This could easily become the ”Tiananmen Square” moment (1989) for the current Iranian regime.

The risks to the oil market are:

1) The current regime applies absolute force. The riots die out and oil production and exports continue as before. Continued US and EU sanctions with Iranian oil mostly going to China. No major loss of supply to the global market in total. Limited impact on oil prices. Current risk premium fades. Economically the Iranian regime continues to limp forward at a deteriorating path.

2) The regime applies absolute force as in 1), but the US intervenes kinetically. Escalation ensues in the Middle East to the point that oil exports out of the Strait of Hormuz are curbed. The price of oil shots above  $150/b.

3) Riots spreads to affect Iranian oil production/exports. The current regime does not apply sufficient absolute force. Riots spreads further to affect oil production and export facilities with the result that the oil market loses some 1.5 mb/d to 2.0 mb/d of exports from Iran. Thereafter a messy aftermath regime wise.

Looking at the oil market today the Brent crude oil price is falling back 0.6% to $63/b. As such the oil market is assigning very low risk for scenario 2) and probably a very high probability for scenario 1).

Venezuela: Heavy sour crude and product prices falls sharply on prospect of reduced US sanctions on Venezuelan oil exports. The oil market take  on Venezuela has quickly shifted from fear of losing what was left of its production and exports to instead expecting more heavy oil from Venezuela to be released into the market. Not at least easier access to Venezuelan heavy crude for USGC refineries. The US has started to partially lift sanctions on Venezuelan crude oil exports with the aim of releasing 30mn-50mn bl of Venezuelan crude from onshore and offshore stocks according to the US energy secretary Chris Wright. But a significant increase in oil production and exports is far away. It is estimated that it will take $10bn in capex spending every year for 10 years to drive its production up by 1.5 mb/d to a total of 2.5 mb/d. That is not moving the needle a lot for the US which has a total hydrocarbon liquids production today of 23.6 mb/d (2025 average). At the same time US oil majors are not all that eager to invest in Venezuela as they still hold tens of billions of dollars in claims against the nation from when it confiscated their assets in 2007. Prices for heavy crude in the USGC have however fallen sharply over the prospect of getting easier access to more heavy crude from Venezuela. The relative price of heavy sour crude products in Western Europe versus Brent crude have also fallen sharply into the new year.

Iran officially exported 1.75 mb/d of crude on average in 2025 falling sharply to 1.4 mb/d in December. But it also produces condensates. Probably in the magnitude of 0.5-0.6 mb/d. Total production of crude and condensates probably close to 3.9 mb/d.

Iran officially exported 1.75 mb/d of crude on average in 2025 falling sharply to 1.4 mb/d in December.
Source: Data by Bloomberg and US EIA

The price of heavy, sour fuel oil has fallen sharply versus Brent crude the latest days in response to the prospect of more heavy sour crude from Venezuela.

The price of heavy, sour fuel oil has fallen sharply versus Brent crude the latest days in response to the prospect of more heavy sour crude from Venezuela.
Source: SEB graph, Bloomberg data feed
Fortsätt läsa

Guldcentralen

Aktier

Annons

Gratis uppdateringar om råvarumarknaden

*

Populära